You must be registered and logged-in to comment.
![]() | dajama said 87 days ago |
|
A true epic The length is good, I think; as you say, it describes a kind of arc, and it would be hard to say what could be cut without destroying that. Your voice on this is excellent, really rich and expressive. The instrumentation is really nice, and I think you've got the balance just right. I don't feel qualified to comment on the details of the sound, but nothing really stands out to me as problematic. A wonderful performance. Thanks for sharing this. Nicely done. Peace. |
![]() | caroline said 87 days ago |
|
WOW - i love this song - always have ... now i love the flute, the arrangement, your voice and the mood of the whole piece and into my itunes it goes where it will be much listened too - ty so much for making it a d/l - big loves xoxoxoxo |
![]() | Dee1962z said 87 days ago |
|
I Am A Poor Wayfaring Stranger This is superb However, I am not an expert but to my two ears it sounds perfect. Love that Flute. Its spot on because I like to play the flute on the software instruments. That much I can say.Music Lyrics and vocas are fantastic. Thanks for sharing your ' Gorgous' Music. Peace Dee. |
![]() | jiguma said 87 days ago |
|
Bing! Song Writing/Content: Can't really comment on songwriting for obvious reason that it's a trad tune. Content - not sure what that means, but I think (for what it's worth) that the embellishments and arrangement you've made sound fantastic. Production/Performance: The performance is top class - but I agree with Eduard about the flute. I love the sound it makes, but at the start in particular it seems to clip, rendering it almost painful on the ears. The flute could certainly take a little reduction in volume throughout. Other instrumentation, vocals, harmonies are outstanding as I've come to anticipate from your posts. Originality/Creativity: The way you've added your own touch to this through instrumentation and arrangement is impressive. It's not one of my favourite tunes, but I really enjoyed your interpretation. Overall rating in genre: It's very good, although different to my concept of "gospel" (that's not a problem of course). Bing, you add a touch of class to everything you touch. Neil |
![]() | Pete_NB said 86 days ago |
|
I'm betting... ...that whoever wrote this song so many generations ago would be floored and approving of what you've done here. You've always been one to listen to around here but you've evolved strongly since your last MJ stint. My skills at production and such aren't in your league so there is nothing I see to critique, and musically speaking, you frickin' nailed it. And I gotta get me one of them whistles! |
![]() | Alannah said 86 days ago |
|
Hints of ..... ... "Summertime" - Billy Holliday) in the intro .... almost wanted to croon along .... then when you started to sing I recognized the Wayfaring Stranger .. (of course) ..... my most recent experience of this tune is the Eva Cassidy Version .... LUV your version ... gave it a deeper treatment ... and depth .... very nice Bing! The Harmonies are truly GLORIOUS !!!! and the instruments ... OH The instruments ..... WOW ! You have truly taken a "folk" tune and risen it to "epic" proportions here ! I felt the full scope of emotion with each note .... |
![]() | John Stebbe said 86 days ago |
|
Moving Bing, this is an excellent track. I especially like the vocal harmony you get when the lyric says "I'm going there." I love the string parts on "Over Jordan." A bit reminiscent of the James Bond theme, in a good, Appalachian way. Reminds me a bit of "My Little Town" by Simon and Garfunkel. I recognized the Native American flute, even before I read your description. I teach elementary music, and there is a track I use with my textbooks which feature a solo Native American flute, and that sound, where it is trying to hop to the next harmonic, is what gives it away. What a great sound. Love the key change at the end. A pleasure, Bing! |
![]() | Lightman- said 86 days ago |
|
Wow Such a peaceful song.... I love the lyrics... And the sound is wide and deep.... Brings peace while listening..... Thanks for sharing this song.... |
![]() | Roxylee said 86 days ago |
|
Glad I heard this I downloaded it to enjoy in my iTunes rotation. Your vocal and instrumental interpretation of this is great! A keeper for sure. I love the NA flute solo. Wow all around. |
![]() | Dragonas said 86 days ago |
|
Bravo! Bravo! A true epic folk song! I am so pleased that you included the musical roots in your description. It really adds a lot of history and emotional value to the song. Really like the flute playing, but if I was gonna really nit-pick, it may have gotten a little busy in a few passages. I like when the flute would hold a note for a while and let it sing. (sounding more vocal) Overall great and definitely right up my alley. Look forward to more! |
![]() | VicDiesel said 85 days ago |
|
Beautiful Professional quality in all respects, playing, arrangement, and production. In particular great job on the native flutes. Good luck with the CD. |
![]() | J.A.Stewart said 85 days ago |
|
Up Front... is where I hear problems, Bing. Ditto for me what Eduard and Neil observed, but also the lead dulcimer(?) in the beginning parts of the song seems to cut through the mix too much, burying the vocal's prominence at times. A little EQ and volume softening, or perhaps a little more spacing should take care of that. I like what you've done with this old jewel. You've given it a soulful luster. ;) --- Joe |
![]() | Micheal_Wark said 85 days ago |
|
Wow! Roxylee and I did a cover of this tune a couple years ago, as did Jack Miller and a few other MJers. I have to say though, that this is my fave of the lot! Nice work Bing! Be well friend! Hmmmnnn....I may have to re-mix and re-post my old version now... |
![]() | MissChaos said 84 days ago |
|
golly Powerful and gorgeous. I was totally lost in this. One little thing. At 1:53, a voice comes in on the left channel and it's seems to clip enough to be harsh on that side. On the shaker... it's a bit mid-heavy. Maybe reducing those frequencies would help it push back into the mix. just a thought. Best of luck with your CD. Let me know when it's available and where to buy it! |
![]() | kassia said 83 days ago |
|
Stranger wow Bing. This is gorgeous. You did a fabulous of melding sounds and styles. I LOVE the key change. It really helps the piece move forward. This is definitely the perfect length. You did an awesome job of building a beautiful, underlying soundbed to support your warm vocals and the dulcimer and flute solos. Dude, this is just breathtaking. My only suggestion (agreeing with what others have said) is the shaker is a little too up front and gets a bit repetitive. Overall, this is definitely a piece to be proud of. beautiful. |
| Dadai said 83 days ago | |
|
Heart and soul... throughout. Atmosphere of the grace of God in your vocals. Bing, this is, in every respect, a worthy version of this old spiritual. Kudos. Jack |
![]() | dreadmon said 80 days ago |
|
Thanks from California Hey all - I will get back to each of you, thanks so much for the input and the kind words. I quickly made some mixing adjustments and got the first pressing of the album out, just in time to fly west to California, where I've been reliving old memories and making new ones. I will probably engage in yet another remix for the next pressing, but your input has been just fantastic, so thank you so much! Will check back in after the festival here. Aloha! |
![]() | spitlogic said 79 days ago |
|
Beautiful Great mix of your dulcimer and the other strings. Very strong subject and the calmness of your voice carries on the story well. Love it. |
| peace-girl said 71 days ago | |
|
I Am A Poor Wayfaring Stranger by dreadmon A TRUE WORK OF ART! Very passionate, very spiritually evoking! Beautiful, in tune voice, and excellent lyrics! Among the best! THANK YOU! |


















First impression - Very crisp, beautifully played and sung piece of music. A couple of things bother me a little on this, mostly because your treatment of this piece is exquisite and feels like it needs a bit of tweaking to remove some minor annoyances... it really wants to soar, and it is close. So...
I LOVE the native American flute work on this, wonderful choice, and gorgeously scored and played. But when it first starts, it sounds almost distorted (clipped), which makes it sound more like a synth flute, not a real played one... perhaps pull it back a little, or add a teeny bit of reverb to it?
Your singing voice is very warm and clear... not sure I would suggest upping the ambient reverb on it.
The dulcimers are beautiful here, and coupled with the rolling rich cello/bass/strings add a lot of depth. I like your scoring of instruments. I might suggest doing a little more overlap here and there... there are spaces that you leave wide open, and the listener loses some continuity and the piece loses a little momentum. You continue to build the piece in each section, just as I was hoping you would, and that was very satisfying.
At 4:42, you have a shaker that comes in, and it feels far too repetitive and "up-front" to me... and there's also an occasional bass drum hit there that is way too far back, and has no "oomph". I would like to hear that drum grow then fade at the end of the piece.
I completely agree, the length of the piece is perfect. Really does breathe, and gives time for it all to sink in.
ttfn,
Drakonis