You must be registered and logged-in to comment.
![]() | I.G.M. said 316 days ago |
|
Hey Tobin :) Sounds a lot like Yes-Zappa-Genesis-Jethro Tull. Amazing stuff, really! One question: there`s something strange in my ear, is it live played? Don`t sounds like it is... I.G.M. |
![]() | Roxylee said 316 days ago |
|
I'm impressed with the band's ability to persevere through all the trials and get this done, and so perfectly. The guitar and vocals are amazing, and everything in here works together so well! You really paint a vivid picture of city life, withe the music giving the lyrics energy and edginess. It is evident this took a lot of time and effort to develop, and it was well worth it. Kudos to all! |
![]() | Doadars Uncle said 316 days ago |
|
Nice! A bit of Yes. Sweeping syncopation and rhythm. Real pleasurable and RICH! |
![]() | dirigent said 316 days ago |
|
Outstanding what a great and powerful, artful and supercool piece of progressive rockmusic. Awesome! great performance and georgious vibe and atmosphere, bravo!! |
![]() | echoroom said 316 days ago |
|
Stunner The quality of musicianship on this is really stunning.... i can't even comprehend it! I have the album and it's fantatsic - very diverse, rich... as Scott says, true art. |
![]() | Godchaser said 316 days ago |
|
Textural Heaven. Complete satisfaction.Beautiful piece of progressive rock.Stellar production,arrangements and perfromances.Top shelf for sure! Blessings, |
![]() | kclements said 316 days ago |
|
Nice work Not really my style, but I really appreciate the textures and performances - top notch. Great interplay between the instruments and vocals and the harmonies are great. I really liked how you are able to blend in the softer sections with the main themes and give it variety. Thanks for sharing - perhaps I could grow to like this style/album. |
![]() | jiguma said 316 days ago |
|
Hmmmmmmm! I'm a huge fan of Yes, Genesis, Gentle Giant, Tull, King Crimson et al, so this is right up my alley. The Yes style on the vocals is uncanny, and where did you get Steve Howe from?! The singing/playing/arrangement and production are awesome, and everyone deserves huge credit for the result. I'm lost for words Tobin - amazing! Neil |
![]() | Feter said 316 days ago |
|
PUZZLE CITY ye nothing is easy .and I bless the giant work . such precious friends gathered into building this incredible work .Deep Bow !! |
![]() | peacepiano said 316 days ago |
|
progress Superb progressive rock. Huge sound. Love this stuff!! Thanks Bill |
![]() | Vic Holman said 316 days ago |
|
everything prog very complicated, yet flows so smoothly. and HUGE! this really sums up the best of ELP and Yes. Actually I hould say you picked up the torch and ran with it. EXCELLENT! |
![]() | paul f. page said 316 days ago |
|
I have been... ...following the various posts of this collection. Tobin, every single piece is so impressive...very complex, smartly orchestrated, engaging and complicated vocals, and such attention to the recorded details. You set the bar...well...it's way up there, that's for sure. I am thinking that it's maybe only you who can reach it because your comps are so unique. I learn something new with each listen to a new number from you. Best of luck on this project. Peace. Paul |
![]() | thetiler said 315 days ago |
|
Enjoy all the music in this wonderful piece. It seems like this really shows your vocal talents to great degree. Harmonizations, high vocal sounds. Lots of really cool music going on here. I think the guitar in indeed very creative in the the descending lead sounds that go hand in had with the falling words etc. Everything you put out to my ears seems at a high level of musical craftsmanship. Thanks for sharing! |
| Roca_Atomica said 315 days ago | |
|
Set the bar? Yeah, I'm pretty sure you have for this genre. Wow. Never a dull moment. Sure, Gentle Giant and Yes come through here and there, but it's unique and special. Very evocative lyrics as well. So sorry to hear about all the misfortunes along the way. |
![]() | stephendavis said 315 days ago |
|
swell Very nice! Cool sound. Interesting all the way through. The guitar is sweet here. |
![]() | thoddi said 314 days ago |
|
Tobin This project is very cool. The power of using the internet as an interface to collaborate on music is manifested in this CD. The song here is energetic and very suited as the companion to the words "The City is phantom, The City is anonymity, The City is breathing, The City is where I come to be. I just wrote a little contribution to a forum post about the CD release here: http://www.macjams.com/forum/viewtopic.php?forum=4;showtopic=117200 |
![]() | stephendavis said 314 days ago |
|
wow! I just felt like I had to comment again... this song has been running through my head all day. LOVE it!!! |
![]() | CharlyDeeCynthius said 314 days ago |
|
Great Song!!! Very appreciated!Tune so cool, remind me to the 70's and early 80's Tony Banks compositions...Very good! CharlyDeeCynthius|Italy| |
![]() | The Infinites said 312 days ago |
|
Prog-proper This is the real deal, as big and grand as the genre should be! Glad you put this up because as an excerpt - it really does make me want to hear the next bit of the story (same feeling as Rush 2112). It's all been said, Yes, Genesis - but wow! To be doing this now using gear from back in the day gives it a feeling of a newly discovered 70s masterpiece. Very powerful music, but also in images from the lyrics - your words just take me straight downtown. Lest we forget. Stunning production and how you managed to knit it all together is beyond me; just as well that you have a jazz ear and can deal with the crazy timings! Nice work Tobin, you should be proud. Jim |
![]() | Karmatoburn said 311 days ago |
|
gentle giant wow, to read all the adversity you guys had to overcome to make this makes it all the more remarkable. Glad you stuck with it. The amount of passion that went in to this really shows. |
![]() | Bowman said 309 days ago |
|
A New Genesis Liked the passion and energy from this. I'm from New York - born and raised. Living there in the 70's listening to progressive rock was in many ways mind blowing and growing. This in a wonderful fresh way takes me to that time and place. Thanks for the trip Tobin. Best, Charlie |
![]() | Warren Smith said 309 days ago |
|
One person's intrepretation .... I don't know the story of Audiocracy ("State of Music"?), but this song suggests it's going to be a philosophical/religious journey about putting the pieces of a life puzzle together. Your language is concise, yet simple phrases are loaded with mulitple meanings. Like: "The City is where I come to be" can be read simply as this is the place where I happen to find myself at this particular point and time ... yet it also can be read as a place of expected fulfillment. That second verse is especially potent. Falling tiles and falling angels are lumped together as physical objects, yet "angels beyond proof" suggests a metaphysical explication. One might anticipate a "fallen Angel" of the Miltonian variety, but here the angels, with a lower case "a," are still in the act of falling, having, apparently, not yet hit bottom. "Confetti made of stars" is a great visual for the night sky ... and it also fits nicely with the idea of falling (as in falling stars). And all of these images are a part of the City's big puzzle ... which will have to be assembled and integrated in order "to be." Excellent writing! |
| said 309 days ago | |
|
Great Wow... What a great rhythm... This sounds good... And your vocals are fantastic... Sounds amazing.... Thanks for sharing this song... |
![]() | sschedra said 302 days ago |
|
Wow! and WOW Again! Tobin, your tastes and talents are here in full. I haven't heard music like this in years. This is really great stuff. And hearing all that you guys endured, you have my respect and my support. I must sample some more of your work. You are a very gifted person. I am particularly touched by your son's trauma as I am a bass player (amoung other jack trades). I also have a son who plays. I pray that he will find a way around this (playing opposite handed?) so that he may continue his passion. Stephen |
![]() | magnatone said 299 days ago |
|
Puzzle City Holy Smokes - you're incredible. Love everything about this sound - and so different from your solo piano (of the few I've heard so far) This is so reminiscent to me of my all-time heart-fave band YES - you must've been a fan? This is great - thanks |
![]() | woofer3 said 278 days ago |
|
Forsooth - An excellent and clever work, well written and well performed, and well produced. Really love it.The intro reminded me a bit of a Frank Zappa piece but can't bring to mind which one, - possibly something from The Man from Utopia ? John. |
![]() | Jarvoid said 249 days ago |
|
Roundabout the second minute I was completely hooked. Yes,completely,this is the type of prog rock that is so evocative of the 70's and I believe will become the "classical" music of that era.....Howe you have done this track here squire I do not know but it will keep me aWakeman, listened and downloaded..........ever been influenced by Genesis? Jarvo |
![]() | Jarvoid said 249 days ago |
|
Roundabout the second minute I was completely hooked. Yes,completely,this is the type of prog rock that is so evocative of the 70's and Mor az I believe will become the "classical" music of that era.....Howe you have done this track here squire I do not know but it will keep me aWakeman, listened and downloaded..And er son........ever been influenced by Genesis? Jarvo |
![]() | BossHook said 239 days ago |
|
I am way late to the Tobin party but I will catch up. Reading the "liner notes" here while listening gave me a bit of nostalgia for records. Not to trivialize the tragedies befallen but the story of how it came together despite the setbacks was a cool insight. Thanks for sharing the experience - it certainly breathes like a studio recording done with everyone there so your talents in producing are high ranking. |
![]() | asconejar said 223 days ago |
|
tsada very honest music, human touch is very evident, raw, jazzy, chic korea type of keyboard. Very happy to hear this song but also my sincere sympathy to the troubles you all experience in completing this song. |
![]() | Kori Arashi said 195 days ago |
|
Awesome! This seriously is overly professional and I like it! Keep up the good work! |




























the most Authentic progressive post I've heard here... Yes sets the bar for me on this kind of work... and you have it all going on in this ... the textured layers that interweave to create the foundation... excellent vocals .. really excellent.. but even more compelling is the lyric... you must have tapped into your jones for NYC... there is a certain believability or trueness, and I suspect that it's autobiographical... my close friend work in and loves NYC and as I've grown older, I've also grown out of it... but this sounds very much like his defense's of NY when we mull it over.. and you've crafted wonderful word/pictures... fragments... but the accumulated effect is to paint a true picture... I love it when art does this... completely describe the thing, without ever saying it....