You must be registered and logged-in to comment.
![]() | SlimGirlFat said 1206 days ago |
|
WOW I love this.. the additions from Darren are excellent. I love the off beat changing chords and the singing is fabulous... Great production.. Fab team work and I expect to hear more!!! Slimmie |
![]() | dchapman said 1206 days ago |
|
This was indeed fun. This was a challenging song with the different instruments moving in different ways. Keeping out of the way of the other instruments while adding something new was the challenge. KISS (Keep it Simple, Stupid!) prevailed. The final product is now showing the potential that I envisioned when I heard the song for the first time and Tobin and I agreed there should be guitar. I hope everyone enjoys this piece as much as I enjoyed the collaboration. |
| said 1206 days ago | |
|
More Dynamic Than Before I very much like the new guitar additions and overall production. Very wel done. |
![]() | aclarke said 1206 days ago |
|
Yes! Excellent! |
![]() | chikoppi said 1206 days ago |
|
Magic fingers - real and virtual Many very subtle and yet very effective alterations in this version. The style and tone of the guitar slips right in like magic. One note I failed to make in my comments for the previous version is a compliment for the drum programming. The drum kit is worked all around in this song and is filled with lots of terrific flourishes. Good drum programming takes a lot of attention to detail, moreso than any other instrument I think, and when the details are off it usually sticks out like a sore thumb. The drums here really rise to meet the high standards called for by the overall excellence of this piece. |
![]() | Einarus said 1206 days ago |
|
Great Love the chord progression. Fantastic production. Top-notch track! |
![]() | Del said 1206 days ago |
|
Lyrics of a masterpiece For all the great things people can say about the music and performances on this masterpiece, I still think the lyrics need special mention for their beauty and power. That they are song by a father and son team, the son singing the father's words, makes for a moving experience. Thank you for continuing to perfect this rather amazing piece of music and poetry. |
![]() | ninipe said 1205 days ago |
|
Sounds like the 70`s Reminds me a little bit of the early Genesis or something like that. But, I`m sorry, it`s not nearly as good as stuff like that. It`s a good song, good playing, nice production, pretty good singing but, in my opinion, a little too much constructed. ninipe |
![]() | Warren Smith said 1204 days ago |
|
Revolutions Dang, since my wife and I forgot to have kids, I guess the new true revolution has started without me. Maybe I can still find involvement as an uncle? It's amazing how complex this piece is, both in its components and its variety of performers and producers. Kudos to every one involved, bringing so much talent and passion to one piece of music. It is progessive both in its structure and in its development. Could've this been done outside of macjams? Maybe - but it might also represent another revolution that's underway. |
![]() | SpasmodicMan said 1204 days ago |
|
Macjammer Renaissance Man Revolution: second nature to teens, but they need the right mix of arrogance and innocence. Revolution: what this country is founded on (the original conservatism: conserve individual dignity at all costs!) Revolution: Macjammers in action! I loved the first version, this is better. So great to hear someone that can rock, that can blues, that can jazz, that can mellow out, that can showtune, that can twist heads with abstract complexity, man you do it all. Macjammer Renaissance Man. Keep 'em comin'! |
![]() | Ejh said 1202 days ago |
|
This is tight! And VERY Prog! I hear a lot of ELP...Greg Lake sort of influence...Bill Brufordish drums...some bits of Yes...even Kansas, a bit... The drums in particular seem live and non- mechanical...even have a bit of Neil Peart to 'em...Mr. "How-I-relate-to-drums-is-I-hit-them"...(actual quote or at least paraphrase...) Having the sense that the track was "built", I'm stunned by how tightly meshed it is...it ends up sounding like something someone--not me or anyone I know personally--but someone could play onstage.... I'm not a big prog listener, and this probably isn't what I'd normally listen to for pleasure, but I can relate to it being good in its genre and I can stand back in amazement at the skills it took to bring it into being... Ed |
![]() | Epileptic Gibbon said 1201 days ago |
|
Liked the original version… … but this is better. Nuff said. I'm about to send it off to my radio DJ friend who I hope will like it too. Power to all you young dudes, and keep proggin'! But I still don't think it sounds like Genesis, ELP (well, maybe some of the keyboard sounds are a little Emerson-like) or even Yes (though more them than the other two) … it's closest to a Starcastle track for sure. |
![]() | Cameron said 1201 days ago |
|
Amazing Production!! This version is an improvement over an already excellent previous one. The addition of dchapman's guitar, along with the additional bass and synth and adjusted mix, makes this piece shine even more brightly. The tempo shifts after the beginning section is always a wonderful surprise to hear -- I really like that transition! The subsequent transitions offer a great deal of interest, as well. The percussion is indeed amazing; very realistic. It must have taken an incredible amount of work and care to produce this kind of authenticity. The drums sound very "warm" and natural. Very excellent production and performance on ALL fronts. BRAVO, tutti! Great picture, too. |
![]() | ceeb666 said 1198 days ago |
|
Very Impressive!! Excellent production and song writing. I don't know if you have been likened to Max Webster before? Very similar to this criminally underrated band. Love the drums dude!! Have you heard the BFD (fxpansion) drumming software? Sounds good but might eat up all my 512 Mb Ram!! Will definately investigate Drums on Demand after lisiening to your track. |
![]() | EdensEve said 1198 days ago |
|
Learning with each song I love how your songs are a slow unveiling of your thoughts, like opening your journal and getting special poetry. I learn something about you, about the world, and about myself, as I listen and read. Hearing your son sing your words does indeed make this more special. You have quite a family! |
![]() | magullo said 1172 days ago |
|
NIce!! Very prog!! It sounds great!! The hammond organ remember me ELP a little bit. Good work!! |
![]() | magullo said 1172 days ago |
|
NIce!! Very prog!! It sounds great!! The hammond organ remember me ELP a little bit. Good work!! |
![]() | Isak Sherwood said 1042 days ago |
|
Best of Site Man, this is the best track on the site so far. I had no idea such great stuff was to be had for free... legally. Rock on, Mueller family! |
![]() | Scott Carmichael said 984 days ago |
|
Yes and yes Hi tobin.... 1st thanx for making me feel welcome here.... your comments are as thoughtful and well crafted as your music.... you don't need anyone here to tell you that you are prolific, with a huge pallette.... i wanted to get to you before now but your library is huge... so I'm taking my time with it... but I'm such a Yes fan, and I'm guessing you have some of their influence here.... anyway i won't wait to tell you I loved this and now I own it thanx; Scott.... not that you would need me , but if there's anything I do that you want or need... ask |
![]() | John Stebbe said 728 days ago |
|
A complex work This track has so many aspects to it, it's hard to know what to respond to first. The prog rock influences are certainly upfront, and unapologetically so, which is refreshing. I can easily picture Rick Wakeman playing all of your B3 licks, which are so enjoyable. The addition of the guitar work is an excellent choice as well. This must have taken forever and a day to go from the idea stage to final completion. And you're letting us download it for free! Thank you, Tobin and Anton, and crew, for an excellent track, and a MJ standout. |
![]() | Mcboy said 727 days ago |
|
as i check this out while laying in bed i'm reminded of a rock opera, or rock musical on broadway....i'm guessing u have an affinity for this genre....it shows.......fantastic arrangement and lots of energy......great collab! |
![]() | Scorpjammer said 727 days ago |
|
I missed... ...rating and faving this when you first posted this version, T. This is one of my favorite Macjams rock tunes. Killer vox and harmonies. Everything about it is so well done. You know, I love good, melodic instrumentation and arrangements, but you, Alimar, Tadashi Togawa, and eleveneyes, are a cut-above with your drum work. I know its only part of the whole, but drums fascinate me. You guys incorporate some tastiest rhythms in your pieces. Excellent stuff here, folks! |
![]() | deputydoofy said 704 days ago |
|
Broadway... ...or something. This has a feeling of Opera Rock (or is it Rock Opera). Despite what it's called, I was recently on a cruise that put on some great shows and this song instantly brought me back to those moments. |
![]() | Denny Borsboom said 703 days ago |
|
Great track which has a strong Crimson meets Genesis feel to me, but it's definitely original. Guitar work is very good, as are the vocals. I enjoyed the small added effects on the vocals a lot. I don't want to think about how much work the drum programming must have been; amazing job there. Thanks for posting. Denny |
![]() | alfalpha said 701 days ago |
|
now I have the chance... ...to finally get to listen to Revolution's Son (Part II) The guitar certainly adds an extra element of depth, as does the keyboards. I found the introduction has a contemporary structure (insofar as the initial drum pattern is concerned), whereas the harmonic structure is unapologetically 'Prog' :-) Very 'Keith Emerson harmony meets a Yes Structure in the 21st Century, which is why I enjoyed listening to this rendition. Many Thanks for bringing this piece to my attention Tobin! |
![]() | oniblah said 694 days ago |
|
great prog indeed "Yes", I hear some Yes/Flash style transitions/themes (which I've always liked) Interesting. A progressive tune in true sense. And a Zappa-style guitar to go. Great! |
![]() | breezer said 694 days ago |
|
cool Nice job. Very enjoyable |
![]() | Tadashi Togawa said 693 days ago |
|
Dream travel This song seems to travel around the dream. Mixed rhythm. I feel classics and the opera. |
![]() | Myshkin said 674 days ago |
|
Killer harmonies! Man, this could be Boston! Great track guys. Very of-its-time, the change-ups and the solos work perfectly. Top stuff. |
![]() | rainfice said 660 days ago |
|
i like this tune i can't figure out what it reminds me of. there,s a really cool sound going on right now i don't now how to describe. this is very well produced and arranged. i really like your organ playing. lots of cool stuff in the background. all around good job. |
![]() | Magritte said 641 days ago |
|
My secret addiction! Wow, very much fun. The performances and production on this really add up to a great classic sound. The only thing missing is a flute somewhere, I think. Rock! |
![]() | Norman Goodman said 620 days ago |
|
Cheers mates! Awesome guitar and lead vocal. Your organ playing on this is fantastic. The chord structure and melody in this piece are very well written and brought to life by excellent performances all around. As far as my pinion goes this is a great progressive rock song. |
| said 461 days ago | |
|
Catching up I enjoy all your very different styles of compositions . I enjoy all these changes here . |
![]() | stephendavis said 278 days ago |
|
so good This is incredibly good! Your music is actually the first prog rock I've ever listened to (I know, I'm green) and I love it! You all have done an excellent job with this album! |
![]() | E-Frame Wrecker said 268 days ago |
|
Beautiful song "Beautiful song" In the words of my housemate who has a lot of Genesis CD's.I have to agree with him on this one. I can hear the Genesis, Kansas, and Yes styled 90125 vocals. I like the high harmonies in there. I haven't listened to the previous mixes. This one is quite good. Not sure how to do it but I'd like to hear a little more variation in the texture of the song. Perhaps replace prominent keyboard part with guitar. The drums are brilliant. though I'd like to hear real drums on a piece this rich and complex. Perhaps we'll get a live recording uploaded sometime in the future? The first thing I noticed was the cool picture of your son. Great work! |

































The addition of Darren's guitar, and new synth and organ
embellishmnents truly "round" out this compostion to
express the artform of "Prog" rock. The bass is a little
more evident, and the the additional production has a
brought a completeness to Rev's Son.
Bravo to you Darren on wearing your "prog" hat on this
one. Not too flashy, but the solo at the end is, as we call it
here in WNY, is "tastey".
Great follow up, Tobin. Excellent work Twon, Tobin, and
DC!